Browse our Selection of Super-Premium Ice Cream Flavors

Made with real Wisconsin Dairy and real sugar cane to create the most delicious ice cream flavors with the best quality ingredients. 

Apple Cider Donut

Banana Cream Pie

Belgian Daydream

Birthday Cake

Black Cherry

Black Licorice

Blackberry Lemon Bar

Blue Moon

Blueberry Cheesecake

Brownie Cascade

Butter Pecan

Cake Batter Fudge

Caramel Apple Pie (Seasonal)

Caramel Chaos™

Cherry Chocolate Chip

Chocolate

Cinnamon Stick (Seasonal)

Coconut

Coconut Almond Bliss

Cookie Dough

Cotton Candy Twist

Door County Cherry

Dutch Maid Vanilla

EggNog (Seasonal) 

Heaps of Love™

Iced Latte–Da®

Key Lime Cheesecake

Kitty Kitty Bang Bang™

Lemon Meringue (Seasonal)

Mackinac Island Fudge

Malt Amore

Mango Untamed

Maple Nut

Matcha Green Tea

Me Want Cookie™

Mint Avalanche 

Mint Chip

Moose Tracks®

Munchie Madness

Old Fashioned Vanilla

Party Animal™

PB Hearts Chocolate®

Espresso Almond Fudge

Espresso Oreo

Exhausted Parent®

Fat Elvis

Gingerbread Man (Seasonal)

Halley's Comet®

Apple Cider Donuts 

Apple cider ice cream, apple cider donut pieces with a cinnamon sugar swirl.

Banana Cream Pie

Your favorite comfort food now on a cone! Banana ice cream churned with a marshmallow ripple and real Nilla Wafers.

Belgian Daydream

Buttermilk waffle ice cream packed with Belgian waffle bites and ribbons of brown sugar–maple goodness.

Birthday Cake

Forgo your fork and grab your spoon! Pop the lid to reveal rainbow bursts of fun confetti sprinkles packed into rich, yellow cake ice cream and topped off with festive swirls of blue buttercream frosting.

Black Cherry

Simply sweet black cherry ice cream with boat-loads of whole black cherries.

Black Licorice

Rich, creamy, and luxurious black licorice flavor balanced with the right amount of sweetness.This flavor isn’t for the masses, but if black licorice is your thing, it’s a cult favorite you cannot miss.

Blackberry Lemon Bar

Fresh lemon ice cream folded with pound cake pieces and swirls of blackberry sauce.

Blue Moon

Just like the milk in the bottom of a Fruit Loops bowl, this tasty ice cream has a sweet Fruit Loops taste and a wacky blue color.

Blueberry Cheesecake

Delectably smooth cheesecake ice cream topped off with a tangy blueberry ripple and soft cheesecake chunks.

Brownie Cascade

Classic, creamy chocolate ice cream exploding with brownie pieces, caramel cups and a sweet fudge ripple.

Butter Pecan

Buttery pecan ice cream with boat-loads of crispy, lightly roasted and salted pecans.

Cake Batter Fudge

With a scrumptious cake batter-base, thick chocolate frosting swirls and brownie chunks, this ice cream settles all arguments over the mixing spoon!

Caramel Apple Pie

Spicy cinnamon ice cream mixed with chunks of real apples, crispy cinnamon shortbread pieces and a thick caramel ripple. This is a seasonal flavor. 

Caramel Chaos™

Sweet caramel ice cream packed with chocolate-covered caramel cups and swirls of gooey caramel.

Cherry Chocolate Chip

Sweet vanilla ice cream loaded with big, red cherries and melt-in-your-mouth chocolate chips.

Chocolate

All-natural, classic chocolate ice cream made with real, rich cocoas.

Cinnamon Stick

Our all natural, tantalizing spicy-yet-smooth cinnamon flavored ice cream.

Coconut

Smooth, sweet, creamy and infused with coconut goodness.

Coconut Almond Bliss™

Tropical coconut ice cream with tons of melt-in-your-mouth chocolate flakes and crispy almond pieces.





Cotton Candy Twist

Blue and pink cotton candy ice creams spun together for that whimsical carnival sensation!



Door County Cherry

All-natural vanilla ice cream loaded with tart Door County cherries from Sister Bay, Wisconsin.



Dutch Maid Vanilla

Sweet, classic and all-natural made with Wisconsin cream, cane sugar and pure vanilla.



Egg Nog

A holiday favorite! Decadently smooth ice cream brimming with traditional eggnog flavor.


Espresso Almond Fudge

This revamped retro flavor is rich espresso ice cream swirled with thick chocolate fudge and crunchy praline almonds.


Espresso Oreo

Crisp coffee-infused ice cream loaded with heaps of sweet Oreos.

Exhausted Parent®

Bourbon-spiked espresso ice cream swirled with bittersweet chocolate chunks.

Fat Elvis

Sweet banana ice cream all shook up with a salty peanut butter ripple and rich chocolate chips.

Gingerbread Man

Brown sugar gingerbread ice cream swirled with white icing glaze and festive holiday sprinkles.

Halley's Comet®

Sweet banana ice cream all shook up with a salty peanut butter ripple and rich chocolate chips.

Heaps of Love™

Anything and everything you can want! Oreos, brownies, cookie dough, pecans, caramel and chocolate ripples all packed into vanilla ice cream.

Iced Latte Da™

Fantastic Wisconsin-made caffeinated espresso ice cream with fudge swirls and chocolate chunks.

Key Lime Cheesecake

Replacing Key Lime Pie – Tart key lime ice cream packed with graham cracker pieces and loads of gooey cheesecake bites

Kitty Kitty Bang Bang™

Irresistibly smooth cheesecake ice cream mixed with a sweet raspberry ripple, Oreo cookies and soft chocolate chunks.

Lemon Meringue

Fresh lemon and fluffy marshmallow ice creams swirled together with a tart lemon ripple.

Mackinac Island Fudge

Sweet vanilla ice cream with a melt-in-your-mouth chocolate fudge ripple and chunks of rich chocolate fudge.

Malt Amore

Old-style malted milk ice cream packed with rich, malt flavor, soft chocolate chips and ripples of sweet, chocolate fudge.

Mango Untamed

Sweet mango ice cream mixed with Tajin and a kick of spicy heat.

Maple Nut

Heavenly sweet maple ice cream brimming with fresh, crunchy walnuts.

Peach (Seasonal)

Peanut Butter Cookie Dough

Peanut Butter Cup

Peppermint Stick

Pistachio Nut

Praline Pecan

Raspberry Rhapsody™

Rhubarb Crumble

Rocky Road

Root Beer Float (Seasonal)

S'more to Love™

Salted Caramel

Scotcheroo

Snap–O-Lantern™ (Seasonal)

Sticks & Stones®

Strawberry

Strawberry Cheesecake

Super Human

This $&@! Just Got Serious®

Turtle

Ultimate Oreo

Vanilla Bean

Vanilla Custard

Yippee Skippee®

Zanzibar® Chocolate

Zanzimint®

Zoreo

Peach

Fresh peach ice cream packed with real peaches to celebrate the warm spring weather, available for a limited time only.

Peanut Butter Cup

Smooth chocolate ice cream brimming with mouthwatering peanut butter ripples and rich peanut butter cups.

Peppermint Stick

Crisp, peppermint ice cream made with boat-loads of peppermint candies and bursting with candy cane flavor in every bite.

Pistachio Nut

Irresistible almond-flavored ice cream churned with crisp pistachio nuts.

Praline Pecan

Buttery maple ice cream topped with a gooey caramel ripple and loads of crunchy, candy-coated pecans.

Raspberry Rhapsody™

Black raspberry ice cream swirled with a sweet raspberry ripple and heavenly chocolate covered raspberry cups.

Rhubarb Crumble

Sweet, cream cheese frosting ice cream, spun with a bright rhubarb jam and a buttery shortbread crumble.

Rocky Road

Swirls of rich, chocolate and fluffy marshmallow ice creams and topped off with chocolate-covered almonds.

Root Beer Float

Creamy vanilla ice cream swirled with crisp root beer Italian ice for a bold new twist on an old favorite.

S'more to Love

Crushed graham cracker ice cream with melty layers of chocolate and marshmallow.

Salted Caramel

A tantalizing blend of sweet, rich caramel and mouth-watering sea salt.

Scotcheroo

Ope, a twist on your favorite Midwest dessert bar! Butterscotch peanut butter ice cream folded with chocolate-covered rice crisps. 

Snap-O-Lantern®

An award-winning combination of spicy pumpkin ice cream and heaps of gingersnap cookies.

Sticks & Stones®

Soft cookie dough chunks, crunchy chocolate covered pretzels, and a gooey salted caramel ripple all swirled into our rich chocolate ice cream.

Strawberry

Award-winning and deliciously fresh strawberry ice cream loaded to the brim with real, whole strawberries.

Strawberry Cheesecake

Cheesecake ice cream swirled with a strawberry ripple and loads of gooey cheesecake pieces.

Super Human

Meet your new kryptonite… Cherry, Blue Moon and Vanilla ice creams combine forces to bring you one super scoop!

This $&@! Just Got Serious®

Award-winning, smooth salted caramel ice cream brimming with rich sea salt fudge and salted cashews.

Turtle

Classic vanilla ice cream with swirls of rich chocolate fudge, gooey caramel and lightly roasted and salted pecans.

Ultimate Oreo

Scrumptious Oreo crumb ice cream packed with boat-loads of whole Oreo cookies.

Vanilla Bean

Sweet, classic and all-natural ice cream made with Wisconsin cream, cane sugar, pure vanilla extracts and vanilla bean flecks.

Vanilla Custard

Sweet, classic and all-natural custard made with Wisconsin cream, cane sugar, egg yolks and pure vanilla.

Yippee Skippee®

Creamy peanut butter ice cream loaded with salted caramel ripples, soft brownie chunks and crispy chocolate-covered pretzels.

Zanzibar® Chocolate

All-natural and award-winning chocolate ice cream made with three kinds of cocoa for a rich, fudge brownie taste.

Zanzimint®

Zanzibar® chocolate ice cream swirled with crisp mint ice cream.

Zoreo

Fudge-like Zanzibar® Chocolate ice cream swirled with gooey marshmallow, Oreos and bittersweet chocolate chunks.

"We frequent Crave Ice Cream Social a little too frequently. My kids will ask almost daily after dinner if we can have Crave! And a couple times a month I give in! Apologies for the nights we come in just 15 minutes before closing!!:wink: But the staff is always so friendly and accommodating! I love that they have non-dairy options, and my youngest son loves their smoothies! We even love to get a pint every now and then and surprise a neighbor with Crave Ice Cream on one of our trips! Truly a gem of a locally-owned shop here in Fishers!"

-Angela

The Sweet Spot Everyone’s Talking About!

"Easily one of our favorite ice cream places in Indy."

-Amanda

The Sweet Spot Everyone’s Talking About!

"Delicious ice cream! Cute, fun, and clean environment!
I highly recommend this place!"

-Juliana

The Sweet Spot Everyone’s Talking About!

"Crave is the best! We like to grab a shake or ice cream cone during the summer after a long day out on the lake!"

-Sofia

The Sweet Spot Everyone’s Talking About!

Sweet Treats:

COME SEE US

Sundaes, cookie sandwiches, drumsticks, and fresh-baked cookies.

28 Rotating Flavors:

COME SEE US

At Vintage Spoon Ice Cream Social, we’re all about delivering happiness in every scoop. Here’s what you’ll find when you visit us:

Cool Refreshments:

COME SEE US

Milkshakes, shaved ice, smoothies, and Starbucks coffee.

Always something new to try, including vegan and dairy-free options.

HOME

PRESS

CONTACT

FLAVORS

ABOUT

FRANCHISE